Is Qualifying In The Top Ten A Good Sign For Kikkan?

So US coach Chris Grover mentioned to FasterSkier.com that he thought that when Kikkan Randall qualifies in the top ten that’s a really good sign that she has a good chance to make the finals.

I did this once before with an interesting quote of his, and I feel kind of bad.  I’m not trying to pick on him, but this is such an obvious thing to check with some actual data, I just can’t pass it up.

Here’s Randall’s qualification and final ranks for WC, WSC and OWG sprint races:

I’ve highlighted the top ten in qualification (vertical red rectangle) and the top six (horizontal red rectangle).

This is a classic conditional probability question.  Given that Randall qualifies in the top ten, what’s the probability that she makes the final?  As far as I can tell the answer is 7/11 or around 63%.  (If you try counting the dots yourself, you won’t get these numbers, as there is some over-plotting going here.)

This is a really small sample size, so I would be loath to conclude here that Grover is right, statistically speaking.  The good news (for Grover!) is that I can’t really conclude that he’s wrong either.  On the other hand, every time (all 11 of them) Randall qualified in the top ten, she eventually made the semis (versus the 6 times she made the semis w/out qualifying in the top 10), which is about the same at around 64%.  Now the sample size is a tad bigger, so maybe Grover’s on to something here, as long as we interpret “making the semis” as “having a good chance to make the finals”, which seems fairly reasonable to me.

Just for comparison, here’s the same plot for Andrew Newell, whose qualification/heats tendencies are a subject of much debate:

Related posts:

  1. Andrew Newell: Qualifying vs. Heats
  2. Assessing The Weekend’s Races: Sprint
  3. Düsseldorf Sprint Recap
  4. Recap: Davos Sprint
  5. USST Preview: Kikkan Randall

About Joran

Comments

4 Responses to “Is Qualifying In The Top Ten A Good Sign For Kikkan?”
  1. Cliff says:

    I think that the correlation between top 10 in the qualification – going to the final is a lot stronger for the women than for the men. At least that’s what the commentators on Swedish television say. Could be interesting to see if the statistics confirm that.

Trackbacks

Check out what others are saying about this post...
  1. […] This post was mentioned on Twitter by WoXC_D, statskier. statskier said: Is Qualifying In The Top Ten A Good Sign For Kikkan? http://goo.gl/fb/fl73X […]

    [WORDPRESS HASHCASH] The comment’s server IP (208.74.66.43) doesn’t match the comment’s URL host IP (74.112.128.10) and so is spam.

  2. […] is a follow-up post to an earlier entry where I noted an off-hand comment by US coach Chris Grover that when Kikkan Randall qualifies in the top ten in a sprint race, that this is a good sign that […]



Speak Your Mind

Tell us what you're thinking...
and oh, if you want a pic to show with your comment, go get a gravatar!